The Ultimate Guides
of Custom Packaging Boxes

Poly Mailers Vs Boxes

Poly Mailers Vs Boxes

In the world of shipping and packaging, businesses often grapple with the decision of whether to use poly mailers or traditional boxes. Each option comes with its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and making the right choice can significantly impact a company’s bottom line. This article aims to provide a thorough comparison of Poly Mailers and custom boxes, covering various aspects like cost-effectiveness, environmental impact, durability, and versatility.


Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are generally more cost-effective than boxes. They are lightweight, reducing shipping costs, and their production materials are often cheaper than those of Cardboard boxes. Additionally, poly mailers require less storage space, contributing to overall cost savings.


Cardboard boxes, while sturdy, can be more expensive due to their materials and weight. The cost of shipping is often higher because of the added weight, and the manufacturing process involves more resources.

Environmental Impact

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are made from polyethylene, a type of plastic. While they are lightweight and require fewer resources to produce, their environmental impact is a concern. Polyethylene is not easily biodegradable, contributing to long-term pollution.


Boxes, being made from paper, are more environmentally friendly. They are biodegradable and recyclable, making them a preferred choice for businesses aiming to reduce their ecological footprint. Many consumers today prioritize eco-friendly packaging, and using Kraft boxes aligns with these preferences.

Durability and Protection

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers offer a level of water resistance, protecting the contents from light rain or accidental spills during transit. However, they are not as puncture-resistant as boxes, making them less suitable for fragile items or those requiring additional protection.


Boxes provide superior protection, especially for delicate or breakable items. Their rigid structure helps prevent crushing and bending, ensuring the contents reach their destination intact. However, boxes are not inherently water-resistant, and they may suffer damage if exposed to moisture.


Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are highly versatile and are commonly used for clothing, soft goods, and non-fragile items. They come in various sizes and can be easily customized with branding or Custom Labels. Poly mailers are also well-suited for e-commerce businesses shipping small to medium-sized items.


Boxes offer versatility in terms of size and shape. They are ideal for shipping a wide range of products, including electronics, home goods, and larger items. Custom printing on boxes improves brand visibility, making them a preferred choice for businesses focusing on branding and a professional presentation.

Storage Space

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers have a significant advantage in terms of storage space. They are flat and can be stored in minimal space, making them ideal for businesses with limited storage capacity.


Custom packaging boxes, due to their three-dimensional structure, require more storage space. Businesses need ample room to store a variety of box sizes, which can be a challenge for smaller retailers or those with limited warehousing capabilities.

Customization Options

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are easily customizable, providing an excellent opportunity for branding. Businesses can print logos, slogans, or marketing messages directly on the mailers, contributing to a professional and cohesive brand image.


Packaging boxes offer extensive customization options as well. From choosing specific sizes to printing intricate designs, businesses can create a unique and branded packaging experience for their customers. Customized boxes can improve the unboxing experience, leaving a lasting impression.

Returnability and Reusability

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are not as suitable for return shipments. Once they are opened, they may not retain their original form, and customers may find them less appealing for reuse. This can be a drawback for businesses emphasizing sustainable practices and encouraging customers to return items.


Boxes are more conducive to return shipments. They can be easily reused, either for returns or for other purposes, promoting sustainability and reducing waste. This can be a significant factor for environmentally conscious businesses looking to establish a closed-loop packaging system.

Sustainability and Eco-Friendly Practices

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers, being made from polyethylene, are not considered environmentally friendly. However, advancements in technology have led to the introduction of recycled and recyclable poly mailers, offering a more sustainable option. Businesses increasingly opt for these eco-friendly alternatives to reduce their environmental impact.


Boxes continue to be a preferred choice for sustainability-conscious businesses. The ease of recycling and the availability of recycled materials make cardboard boxes an eco-friendly option. Some companies even use biodegradable or compostable packaging solutions to further increase their commitment to sustainable practices.

Security and Tamper Resistance

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers, being lightweight and flexible, may lack the inherent security features that boxes provide. They are susceptible to tampering, and while some poly mailers come with tamper-evident seals, they may not offer the same level of security as a sealed box.


Rigid boxes offer a higher level of security due to their rigid structure. Once sealed, they are more challenging to tamper with, providing added protection for valuable or sensitive items during transit.

Impact on Brand Image

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers, when customized with vibrant designs and branding, can contribute positively to a brand’s image. They offer a modern and sleek appearance, which may appeal to certain demographics, especially in the e-commerce sector.


Customized boxes can raise a brand’s image significantly. The ability to print intricate designs, logos, and engaging content on boxes improves the overall unboxing experience for customers. High-quality packaging can leave a lasting impression and contribute to brand loyalty.

Speed and Efficiency in Packaging

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are quicker and easier to pack, requiring less time and labor. This can be advantageous for businesses with high shipping volumes, streamlining their Packaging Process and improving overall efficiency.


Packaging items in boxes may take more time and effort, especially when dealing with a variety of sizes and shapes. However, advances like automated box packing systems are helping businesses increase efficiency in the packing process.

International Shipping Considerations

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers are a popular choice for lightweight international shipments. They contribute to lower shipping costs, making them an attractive option for businesses expanding their reach globally.


Boxes, while heavier and potentially more expensive for international shipping, provide better protection for items during long-distance transit. Choosing the right packaging solution may depend on the nature of the products and the level of protection required for international shipments.

Regulatory Compliance and Shipping Restrictions

Poly Mailers

Poly mailers, being lightweight and flexible, are often subject to specific shipping regulations and restrictions. Some countries or carriers may have limitations on the use of poly mailers, especially for certain types of products.


Boxes generally comply with international shipping regulations and are accepted by most carriers. However, businesses should still be aware of size and weight restrictions imposed by shipping services to avoid any complications during transit.


The choice between poly mailers and boxes depends on various factors, including the nature of the products, shipping costs, environmental considerations, and brand image. Poly mailers are cost-effective and suitable for lightweight, non-fragile items, while boxes offer superior protection and are more environmentally friendly. Businesses need to weigh these factors carefully and, in some cases, may even opt for a combination of both packaging options to meet different shipping needs. Ultimately, understanding the unique advantages and limitations of poly mailers and boxes is crucial for making informed decisions that align with a company’s goals and values.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Boxes or Mailers Better?

Mailers are often preferred for lightweight and non-fragile items due to their flexibility and cost-effectiveness. Boxes provide better protection for delicate or heavy items. The choice depends on the nature and size of the items being shipped.

What Is the Difference Between Mailer Boxes and Shipping Boxes?

Mailer boxes are typically self-sealing, lightweight, and designed for smaller items. Shipping boxes are sturdier, suitable for larger or heavier items, and may require additional sealing. Mailer boxes are more compact, while shipping boxes vary in size.

What Are the Advantages of Using Cardboard Boxes as Opposed to Plastic Mailers?

Cardboard boxes are eco-friendly, recyclable, and provide better protection. They are also more versatile, accommodating various shapes and sizes. Plastic mailers are lightweight and water-resistant but may not offer the same level of protection.

Can I Put a Box in A Poly Mailer?

Yes, placing a box inside a poly mailer is feasible for added protection. However, ensure the poly mailer’s size accommodates the box, and consider the nature of the items being shipped.

Is It Cheaper to Mail Poly Mailer or Box?

Poly mailers are often cheaper to mail than boxes due to their lighter weight. For non-fragile items, poly mailers are a cost-effective choice, while boxes may be necessary for delicate or heavier items.

Is It Cheaper to Ship Boxes or Poly Mailers?

Shipping costs depend on weight and dimensions. Poly mailers are generally cheaper for lighter items, while boxes may incur higher costs for heavier or larger shipments. Evaluate the specific requirements for cost-effective choices.

What Are the Disadvantages of Boxes?

Boxes can be bulky, adding to shipping costs. They may also require additional packing material for cushioning, and their weight can contribute to higher shipping expenses.

What Are the Disadvantages of Using Boxes?

Using boxes can lead to increased packaging waste. They may not be as suitable for certain items, such as clothing, where poly mailers could offer more flexibility and cost savings.

Why Are Boxes So Expensive?

The cost of boxes is influenced by materials, size, and weight. Sturdy materials and larger sizes can increase manufacturing costs, and heavier boxes incur higher shipping expenses, contributing to overall pricing.

Are Boxes More Expensive to Ship Than Envelopes?

Yes, boxes are generally more expensive to ship than envelopes due to their weight and size. Envelopes, especially lightweight ones like poly mailers, often incur lower shipping costs compared to larger and heavier boxes.

What Kind of Boxes Are Best for Shipping?

The best boxes for shipping are corrugated cardboard boxes. They provide durability, protection, and are lightweight, making them ideal for transporting various items.

Which Boxes Are Best for Shipping?

Corrugated cardboard boxes are the preferred choice for shipping. They offer a balance of strength and weight, ensuring items are well-protected during transit without adding excessive shipping costs.

Which Is Cheaper for Shipping Boxes?

Corrugated cardboard boxes are typically more cost-effective for shipping due to their lightweight nature and ease of production, making them economical for both businesses and individuals.

Should You Ship Clothes in A Box or Bag?

Shipping clothes in a box is generally recommended to prevent damage and wrinkles. Boxes offer better protection and support, ensuring that garments arrive in good condition, especially for delicate or valuable items.

Are Mailers Still Effective?

Yes, mailers are still effective. They provide a lightweight and cost-efficient option for shipping small items, such as documents, books, or clothing, and are often chosen for their convenience and ease of use.

What Are Mailer Boxes Used For?

Mailer boxes are used for shipping small and lightweight items. They are convenient, easy to assemble, and offer protection during transit. Mailers are commonly employed for sending products like clothing, books, or promotional materials.

Does The Box Matter for Shipping?

Yes, the choice of box matters for shipping. The right box ensures that items are adequately protected during transit, reducing the risk of damage. Corrugated cardboard boxes are widely recommended for their strength and reliability.

What Is the Success Rate of Mailers?

The success rate of mailers is generally high, especially for small, durable items. Properly packaged mailers provide protection and secure shipping, contributing to a positive delivery experience for recipients.

Are Mailers Effective for Advertising?

Yes, mailers are effective for advertising. They offer a tangible and eye-catching way to showcase promotional materials, catalogs, or product samples, creating a direct and engaging connection with the audience.

Are Carton Boxes Better Than Plastic?

Carton boxes are often preferred over plastic for shipping due to their recyclability, cost-effectiveness, and better ability to absorb shocks. Plastic may be used for specific items, but carton boxes are generally more versatile and eco-friendly.

What Size Boxes Are Best for Shipping?

For shipping, it’s ideal to choose boxes that snugly fit your items to prevent damage. Standard sizes like 12x12x12 or 16x16x16 work well for a variety of goods.

What Are Boxes Used For?

Boxes serve diverse purposes, from packaging and storage to transportation. They protect items during transit, help organize, and contribute to efficient handling across various industries.

What Are Boxes Called?

Boxes go by various names such as cartons, packages, or containers, depending on their size, shape, and usage in different contexts.

What Size Is A 30 Kg Carton?

The size of a 30 kg carton depends on the dimensions and density of the contents. It’s best to calculate based on the specific items being packed to ensure a secure fit.

How to Get Free Parcel Boxes?

Free parcel boxes can be obtained from local post offices, shipping companies, or online retailers. Some services provide complimentary boxes for specific shipping needs.

What Is the Concept of a Box?

In geometry, a box is a three-dimensional shape with six rectangular faces. In a broader sense, the term “box” is often used colloquially to refer to any container with enclosed sides and a lid.

What Is Used to Make Boxes?

Boxes are typically made from cardboard, corrugated fiberboard, or paperboard. These materials offer durability while being lightweight and cost-effective.

What Are the Four Functions of Boxes?

Boxes serve four primary functions: containment, protection, ease of handling, and promotion. They enclose items securely, shield them from damage, facilitate transportation, and often display branding.

What Is Boxes Packaging?

Boxes packaging involves using boxes to encase and protect products during storage, handling, and transportation. It plays a crucial role in safeguarding goods and promoting a brand through design and labeling.

You May Also Like...

Go from beginner to pro with our step-by-step custom box packaging resource guides. Get up to speed on the latest trends and must-know tips about product photography, box templates, box design, retail e-commerce, eco-friendly boxes, shipping strategy, box sizes, branding and more from a trusted industry leader.

Request A Callback